'Had I said (Nehru's) Himalayan blunder…': Amit Shah's dig as Congress walks out

It was not a mistake. It was a blunder to lose so much land of this country." : Shah

Manoj Kumar Pathak

New Delhi, Union Home Minister Amit Shah's recent comments on Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru sparked controversy in Parliament on Wednesday, leading to a dramatic walkout by several Congress MPs.

During his address, Shah pointedly held the former Prime Minister responsible for the contentious issue of Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (POK). "The problem of Pakistan Occupied Kashmir occurred because of Pandit Nehru. Otherwise, that part would have belonged to Kashmir. Nehruji was responsible for POK," asserted Shah.

The Home Minister didn't mince words, declaring, "Nehru ji said it was his mistake. It was not a mistake. It was a blunder to lose so much land of this country." These strong remarks by Shah, known for his direct and assertive communication style, drew immediate reactions from Congress members present in the Parliament.

In response to Shah's comments, a group of Congress MPs decided to stage a walkout, expressing their disagreement with the characterization of Nehru's actions. The walkout marked a moment of tension in the parliamentary proceedings and highlighted the ongoing political discourse around historical decisions and their consequences.

Amit Shah's use of the term "Himalayan blunder" to describe Nehru's actions in relation to POK adds fuel to the ongoing political debates over India's territorial integrity and historical decisions. The exchange in Parliament is likely to reverberate in the political landscape, with discussions and reactions expected to continue in the coming days.

Reacting to Opposition MPs walking out, Shah said, "They are so upset over the word blunder. If I had d said 'Himalayan', they would have resigned and left."

According to the Home Minister, Jammu and Kashmir suffered due to two "blunders"by Nehru - announcing a ceasefire and taking the Kashmir issue to the United Nations.

"If there had been a ceasefire after three days, PoK would have been a part of India today... The second is to take our internal issue to the UN," the Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) leader said.

Shah also said "PoK is ours", as he said that 24 seats were reserved there.

"Earlier, there were 37 seats in Jammu, now there are 43. Earlier there were 46 in Kashmir, now there are 47 and in PoK, 24 seats have been reserved since PoK is ours," Shah said.

His remarks came during a discussion on The Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, 2023 and The Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2023

Delhi’s Diwali: A Festival of Lights, a Failure of Civic Sense

Delhi's Diwali pollution exposes a deeper civic crisis as firecracker violations, toxic air and weak enforcement threaten public health and the rule of law.

Dr. Niraj Krishna   |  23 hours ago

Revived Diplomacy, Deep Divides: Why a Breakthrough in Ukraine Remains Out of Reach

Renewed US-Ukraine-Russia talks in Abu Dhabi offer hope for peace, but territorial disputes, security guarantees and European divisions threaten progress.

DINESH DUBEY   |  23 hours ago

Designing Sleep: A Modern Guide to Better Rest

BOOK REVIEW: Explore Joseph Zakher’s Designing Sleep: A Modern Guide to Better Rest, a compelling book on sleep science, mental well-being, Ayurveda and healthier living.

Vijaya Devshree   |  2 days, 2 hours ago

Beyond the Seasonal Rituals: Why Delhi’s Pollution Demands Year-Round Watch

Delhi’s air pollution demands more than seasonal emergency measures. Weak enforcement, industrial emissions, stubble burning and poor urban governance require year-round accountability.

DINESH DUBEY   |  2 days, 4 hours ago

From Target to Attacker: How Rahul Gandhi Flipped the Script on Political Aggression

Rahul Gandhi takes a direct political offensive against PM Modi, challenging the government on economic distress, national security, foreign influence and democracy.

Dr K Ranjan Sharma   |  3 days, 20 hours ago

The Midterm Mandate: How a Democratic Congress Plans to Reclaim Sanctions and Aid for Kyiv

Democrats reclaim Congress after the US midterms, pushing $15 billion in Ukraine aid, tighter Russia sanctions and oversight of Trump's foreign policy.

DINESH DUBEY   |  4 days, 3 hours ago

Comments

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

View More

By Vijaya Devshree   |   2 days, 2 hours ago
Designing Sleep: A Modern Guide to Better Rest