Un-substantiated Complaint does not mean False Complaint

Getting clarity on what constitutes un-substantiated complaints, lying and malicious complaints under Section 14 of the PoSH Act, 2013. This is one of the most important and sensitive areas of the PoSH Act. We need to ensure that women come forward to report Sexual Harassment without fear. However, we also need to ensure that if a person is facing an allegation and are accused of something then they will not be left feeling vulnerable as they may be accused of a completely false and fabricated complaint.

 

This is recognised by the law. The problem occurs when organisations fail to understand the difference between un-substantiated complaints and malicious complaints. This is a very important distinction to make as it can mean that the complainant will be unfairly punished for lack of evidence.

 

1. What does Section 14 of the PoSH Act Say?

 

Section 14 of the PoSH Act relates to punishing those who make false or malicious complaints as well as false evidence. This section gives grounds to punish the complainant if the IC or Local Committee find that:

• The complaint made against the Respondent was malicious.

• The complainant or anyone else who made the complaint knew it was false.

• The complainant or anyone else who made the complaint had provided false or misleading documents.

• A witness had given false evidence or provided false or misleading documents.

 

However, there are also a couple of key points to note. Firstly, it recognises that just because a complaint cannot be substantiated or there just isn’t enough evidence to prove it doesn’t mean that action can be taken against the complainant. Secondly, it must be proven that the complainant had malicious intent through an investigation following the correct procedures. These safeguards are part of the law itself. They cannot be ignored by an employer or an Internal Committee. 

 

2. Three Different Scenarios must not be confused

There is a significant difference between the following scenarios.

 

A. Un-substantiated Complaint

A woman makes a complaint but there isn’t enough evidence to support it. For example there may be no independent witness, no electronic evidence and nothing else to prove her claim. The IC may conclude that the complaint cannot be substantiated. This doesn’t mean that the woman was intentionally making a false complaint.

 

B. Incorrect Information

The complainant may genuinely believe that the incident happened in a certain way. However, during the investigation it may be found that some of the facts are incorrect. This doesn’t mean that the complainant had malicious intent. The committee need to investigate the circumstances thoroughly. A mistake, misunderstanding or inconsistency does not automatically establish malicious intention.

 

C. Intentionally False/Malicious Complaint

This is completely different. If someone is intentionally making claims about events that did not happen, creating false messages, providing false documents or using the PoSH process to harm another employees’ career then Section 14 of the Act may be applicable to them if it can be proven that they had the necessary facts and malicious intent through a proper investigation.

 

This is important to note as the law recognises that true complaints will be protected even if there isn’t enough evidence.

 

3. Why Section 14 Of The Act Shouldn’t Be Used As A Threat

 

A woman may feel nervous about reporting sexual harassment due to fear of loosing their job, social pressures and having their personal life questioned. If all un-successful complaints are labelled as false then women may be scared to go to the Internal Committee. This goes against what the Act is trying to achieve. However, if there is credible evidence to show that the complaint was intentionally created then this provision cannot be ignored.

 

Instead, it is important to not assume every complaint is true or that every un-successful complaint is malicious. Instead, the facts should be looked at.

 

4. What Needs To Be Considered By The IC Before Recommending Action Under Section 14 Of The Act?

 

The IC shouldn’t recommend any action just because the complaint was unsuccessful. Before recommending action under Section 14 of the act the IC should consider:

1. Were the allegations intentionally false?

2. Is there evidence to show that the complainant intended to mislead the committee?

3. Was there any intentionally false or tampered documents?

4. Is there evidence to show that the allegation of malicious intent is true?

5. Has the complainant had a fair and thorough opportunity to comment on the finding that they had malicious intent?

 

The investigation into whether the complainant had malicious intent needs to be separate to the finding that the allegations couldn’t be proven. There needs to be a reasoned finding and the committee must explain why they have come to that conclusion. They must explain what facts were found to be false, what evidence shows that the complainant knew or intended to do this and why Section 14 is applicable.

 

5. Interesting 2026 Judgement from the Bombay High Court

 

An interesting case to note is Srinivass Shinde v. Directorate of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship & Others, Writ Petition No. 15 of 2026 decided on 20th April 2026 by Justice Dr. Neela Gokhale of the Bombay High Court at Goa. The facts of this case are important to consider.

 

A female employee made a sexual harassment complaint against her colleague. She then retracted her complaint stating that it had been written by her Principal and she had felt pressured and threatened into signing it.

 

She also stated that her colleague had not sexually harassed her. The IC concluded the proceedings and found that the complaint had been made by an unknown person. However, the complainant had specifically stated that it had been made by her Principal. The respondent disputed this.

 

The High Court found that the IC hadn’t noted correctly who the complainant had stated had made the complaint. They ordered that the reference to the unknown person should be changed to the Principal as this was what the complainant had stated. They also made it clear that whilst Section 14 of the Act can be used to take action against those who made the complaint, or a complaint that falls under this section, it cannot be used to punish a third party as they had instigated the complaint. The courtrecognised that the petitioner could take the correct actions against the alleged instigator through the correct forum.

 

What Makes This Case Important? It shows that the IC must look at the real facts of the situation. They shouldn’t assume that the complaint was malicious and should not ignore any evidence that shows why the complaint was made.

 

6. Retraction of A Complaint Doesn’t Automatically Mean Malicious Intent

 

Sometimes a complaint may be retracted. This may be for a number of reasons including:

• Feeling pressured by colleagues/management.

• Fear of the consequences professionally.

• Feeling pressured by family/social circle.

• The issues in the workplace have been resolved between the parties.

• Lack of confidence in how the investigation will be handled.

• Realising that the complaint was based on a misunderstanding.

 

Therefore, the fact that a complaint has been retracted does not automatically mean that the original complaint was malicious. The IC must consider why the complaint was retracted and if there is any evidence to suggest that it was intentionally false. The Bombay High Court decision above is a useful example as in this case the complaint had been retracted with an allegation that it had been written under pressure.

 

7. Can The Respondent Ask For Action To Be Taken Under Section 14of the Act?

 

Yes. Whilst being cleared of the allegations doesn’t automatically entitle them to have the complainant punished, they have the right to provide any relevant evidence to the IC. They can also request examination of whether Section 14 is applicable. For example, the Respondent may provide evidence of:

• False electronic messages.

• Tampered documents.

• Clearly known false statements.

• Evidence to show that the complaint was intentionally created to blame an innocent employee.

 

The IC have a duty to look at this evidence objectively and follow the correct procedures. However, just because the investigation report says that the allegations couldn’t be proven doesn’t mean that the respondent can demand action to be taken against the complainant.

 

An important point to note is that Section 18 of the Act allows for any person who is aggrieved by the recommendations of Section 14 to appeal in accordance with the relevant service rules or procedures. They have 90 days from the date of the recommendations to do this.

 

8. What About False Evidence From Witnesses?

 

Section 14(2) of the Act covers witnesses who provide false evidence or false/misleading documents. This is an important point to note as it is not just the responsibility of the complainant and respondent to ensure everything is fair. Witnesses have a responsibility to be truthful too.However, just because there is conflicting evidence between two witnesses doesn’t mean that one of them has intentionally provided false evidence.The IC must distinguish between differing memories, honest mistakes and intentional falsification. IC should only recommend action if the facts have been proven.

 

9. Risks Of Using Section 14 To Sort Out Workplace Issues

 

The PoSH process should never be used to get personal, deal with office politics, disputes over promotions or professional relationships. Similarly, an employer shouldn’t threaten to take action under Section 14 to try and silence an employee who has reported genuine sexual harassment. A complaint can only be classed as malicious if there is evidence to back it up. Whilst it may make the respondent feel disappointed or aggrieved that the complaint couldn’t be proven guilty this doesn’t mean that the complainant has done anything wrong. The law requires that intention and evidence is carefully considered.

 

10. Conclusion: The Law must protect both TRUTH and FAIRNESS

 

Section 14 of the PoSH Act is an important part of the law however it should be used carefully. If a complaint cannot be proven then this should be clearly stated. If there isn’t enough evidence then this should be clearly stated. If the complaint was intentionally false or based on evidence that the complainant knew was false then there is a process to deal with this. These situations should never be confused. The possibility of action being taken under Section 14 should not put women off reporting real harassment. However, if it can be proven that the complaint was intentionally false then the respondent should have a remedy. The Internal Committee must remember that they have a duty to look at the evidence and make a reasoned conclusion. They should not protect either party by automatically assuming that the other party isn’t telling the truth. Just because a complaint cannot be proven doesn’t mean that it is false. However, if it can be proven that it is false then this shouldn’t be ignored. This is where true fairness can be found in the PoSH Act.

 

(Author, a former AICC member, is a well-rec ognised lawyer-campaigner for female rights, and has authored “Breaking the Silence: A Handbook on the PoSH Act”.)

A Much-Needed Trilateral: Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping Meet at Shenzhen

The Trump-Putin-Xi trilateral meeting in Shenzhen highlights nuclear security, global conflicts, energy cooperation and the future of the international order.

Alok K. Shrivastava   |  an hour ago

Profits Without People: India Inc. Must Honour Its Social Contract

PM Modi urges India Inc. to share economic gains through job creation, fair wages and ethical governance. Why corporate accountability matters for India's growth.

DINESH DUBEY   |  2 hours ago

Western Ghats Deforestation Threatens Lives & Livelihoods

Deforestation in the Western Ghats threatens biodiversity, rainfall patterns, water security and livelihoods. Pump storage and infrastructure projects raise serious ecological concerns.

B K Singh   |  1 day, 1 hour ago

Architects of a Healthy Bloom: Re-engineering India’s Human Capital Infrastructure

Discover how India can transform its human capital through maternal health, early childhood nutrition, teacher reforms, mother-tongue education and decentralised learning.

K. N. Laxminarayan   |  1 day, 2 hours ago

A New Yalta or a Fractured Order?

The Trump-Xi-Putin summit raises questions about a new world order, shifting global power, Gulf security, Iran tensions and the future of international peace.

DINESH DUBEY   |  1 day, 2 hours ago

Islamophobia & the Changing Face of Democratic Politics

Rising electoral victories of Muslim candidates in the US and UK highlight how democratic participation, equal citizenship and inclusive politics can challenge Islamophobia.

Dr. Khwaja Iftikhar Ahmed   |  1 day, 23 hours ago

Comments

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

View More

By Dr. Khwaja Iftikhar Ahmed   |   1 day, 23 hours ago
Islamophobia & the Changing Face of Democratic Politics
By Dr Niraj Krishna   |   2 days ago
“When Reason Fails, Books Are Torn Apart”