Post-Pahalgam Geopolitics: Need to Re-evaluate Our Strategic Alliances

 

The current geopolitical landscape sees India re-evaluating its strategic alliances, driven by escalating tensions with China and a perceived lack of unwavering support from Western powers following recent regional events. This shift in focus underscores a critical period for India's foreign policy and defense strategy.

 

A significant catalyst for this re-evaluation was the recent acknowledgment by India's Deputy Chief of Army Staff, Lieutenant General Rahul R Singh, that China actively aided Pakistan during India's "Operation Sindoor." Speaking at a FICCI event, Singh explicitly stated that China utilized its ancient military doctrine of "36 stratagems," specifically "killing the adversary with a borrowed knife," to provide real-time intelligence and support to Pakistan, essentially using the conflict as a testing ground for its military capabilities against India. This frank admission from a senior Indian military official is a rare public naming of China as a direct threat.

 

The aftermath of the "Pahalgam terror attack" and India's subsequent military response, Operation Sindoor, exposed a gap between India's expectations and the global community's reaction. Many Indians were disappointed that major Western powers, despite being aware of China's military assistance to Pakistan, offered only condemnations of the attack, stopping short of unequivocal support for India's right to self-defense. This perceived lack of robust backing from nations with whom India has actively sought to deepen economic and defense ties in recent decades was a significant letdown.

 

Further compounding this sentiment was the reception of Pakistani military chief Asim Munir by US President Donald Trump at the White House, and General Michael Kurilla's description of Pakistan as a "phenomenal partner." Such gestures reinforced the long-standing Indian concern that Western nations continue to "hyphenate" India with Pakistan, undermining India's efforts to be seen as a distinct and strategically autonomous power in the region, particularly after two decades of cultivating closer ties with the West.

 

Consequently, India is now contemplating a significant recalibration of its strategic relationships, particularly in light of the increasingly close military ties between China and Pakistan. There is a growing consensus within Indian strategic circles that strengthening the strategic partnership with Russia, while simultaneously maintaining robust ties with the United States, is essential to effectively counter the growing Chinese threat.

 

This strategic re-evaluation is buoyed by Russia's recent overtures, including an offer to supply its fifth-generation stealth fighter, the Su-57, virtually on India's terms. This enticing proposal includes the possibility of local production, full source code sharing, and crucial technology transfer – concessions that are rarely, if ever, offered by Western nations for their advanced military systems like the F-35, and which align perfectly with India's "Make in India" defense initiatives.

 

Beyond advanced fighter jets, India and Russia possess a proven track record of successful joint defense ventures, exemplified by the Brahmos supersonic cruise missile, which demonstrated its efficacy in the recent conflict. Discussions are also underway for the potential co-production of the S-500 missile defense system, building upon the successful deployment of the S-400 system against Pakistan, further cementing Russia's role as a critical defense partner.

 

Historically, Russia has proven to be a reliable and steadfast ally for India, a point often recalled in New Delhi. This loyalty was evident during the 1971 war when Russia stood by India despite Western and Chinese support for Pakistan, and again when Moscow refrained from imposing sanctions after India's nuclear tests in 1974 and 1998, unlike many Western nations. Russia's continued support was crucial for India's atomic program during its period of international nuclear isolation.

 

Despite the highly publicized "no-limits partnership" between China and Russia, particularly since the Ukraine war, underlying tensions and suspicions persist. A reportedly leaked FSB intelligence report, describing China as "the enemy," alleges Chinese espionage, attempts to recruit Russian scientists, and encroachment on Russian territories in the Pacific and Central Asia. Such revelations suggest that Russia, under specific circumstances, could be open to reducing its reliance on Beijing.

 

This potential for a loosening of the China-Russia embrace presents an opportunity for the United States, with President Donald Trump having openly expressed a desire to "un-unite" Putin and Xi. Washington views a strong Moscow-Beijing axis as a significant challenge and believes that if Russia can be weaned away from China, the US can then more effectively concentrate its strategic efforts on countering the Chinese threat.

 

However, the Ukraine war continues to serve China's strategic interests, keeping the US preoccupied and diverting American military resources away from the Indo-Pacific. The conflict's continuation also suits Beijing by depleting American military equipment through constant supplies to Ukraine. Conversely, an end to the war could potentially improve US-Russia relations, reduce Moscow's dependence on Beijing, and facilitate the rebuilding of Russia's economy and arms industry, thereby decreasing its reliance on Chinese components and offering a new lifeline to Indo-Russian defense projects.

 

Ultimately, India's strategic balancing act aims to convince its Western partners that its deepened engagement with Russia is not an antagonistic move, but rather a calculated effort to mitigate Moscow's reliance on Beijing, thereby contributing to a more stable multipolar world order. India recognizes the indispensable role of the United States as the sole power capable of truly countering China, and the mutual need for continued strategic partnership between New Delhi and Washington to effectively address the evolving Chinese challenge.

 

(Author, a JNU PhD, formerly served as the Information & Publicity officer in Bihar government.)

 

ADVERTISEMENTS

ADVERTISEMENTS

ADVERTISEMENTS

Comments

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

View More

By Manoj K. Pathak   |   6 hours ago
Latest Innovations Pave the Way to a Sustainable Future
By Dr. K. Ranjan Sharma   |   6 hours ago
Latest Innovations Pave the Way to a Sustainable Future
By Dr. Afroz Ashrafi   |   7 hours ago
Latest Innovations Pave the Way to a Sustainable Future